Yesterday I sent my application for Canadian citizenship via registered mail to the Sydney, Ontario, Processing Centre. An American citizen from birth, I’ve lived outside the USA, first as a student then as a permanent resident of Canada, since 1986. I’ve never really felt that I needed Canadian citizenship. My reason for applying now is that it is inconvenient being an American living in Canada. So before my citizenship ceremony in a year or so, I will be renouncing my US citizenship. Likely, for a few days while awaiting the ceremony, I will be a stateless person. [actually, I became a Canadian on February 28, 2011, and informed the US Consulate in Toronto of my relinquishment on April 7, 2011]
The United States is the only country in the world that requires that all its residents and all its citizens, even if living abroad, pay tax, though there is an earned income exemption of $70,000 [over 90,000 today] and foreign tax, dollar per dollar, credit. The threshold for filing is ridiculously low. As a married person filing a separate return, I must file if I make more than $2000; this despite the knowledge that as a resident of Canada, it is difficult to imagine very many scenarios where I might be liable for tax, since the rate here is higher than in the USA, particularly for lower income earners. But it is a hassle to file every year, and it creates a lot of anxiety for me. Last year, my accountant forgot a certain form and he was sick when I was required to send the amendment, and so I had to do it myself and that created a huge headache.
So I am not going to renounce my citizenship because I owe tax. I am liable to the IRS for nothing. I am doing it first of all because I am tired of filing a frivolous return to the IRS each year; frivolous because I owe nothing, and cannot possibly owe anything living here in Canada.
But there is another even more important reason which I call the “New Berlin Wall”. Since 2008, the US has placed particular restrictions on wealthy people who wish to expatriate. If I were to own 2 million in assets or if my average
net income tax liability over the last five years were $139,000 , I would be a “covered expatriate” upon renouncing my citizenship. The law penalizes these individuals with exorbitant expatriation tax that boggles the mind. Why? To keep them in the USA. So it is a Berlin Wall designed to keep people from leaving the US.
I am long way from being a covered expatriate. But with the devaluation of the dollar due to hyperinflation, I foresee being there soon. Therefore, I’ve decided to leave before the law applies to me; because it was much easier to leave East Berlin before the Wall was built.
Oh and by the way, Go Canada Go!!!
[corrections, 20 April 2011]
I am in the exact same situation as you. I have lived in Canada for thirty years. I have been told by the IRS when I call as I have been a stay at home mom of a disable CANADIAN child that I did not have to file since I did make enough to file but, that I might want to fine and use my husband *who claims me as a dependent** income, he is CANADIAN. I do not have to file him as “American for tax purposes” but, was told I could. Why would I want to do that.
My health is not good and this is such a royal pain. It is exceedingly confusing. This year I inherited some money when my mother passed away. I will of course report it but, it’s right in the middle of this U.S. tax change for citizens residing in other countries. FURTHER now they want me to tell them about all my accounts. Mostly it’s all my husbands income in there again, he is CANADIAN but, I have signing rights on our checking account of course. What to do? One women in the U.K. has never had her name on any of her family accounts so she is a pauper and in my same situation. Her name is not on their house or anything.
Why should people of lower middle income be subjected to this after living outside the country for so long. I no longer have any desire to be American because of these draconian practices. It puts such hardship on law abiding citizens. I want to renounce. The stress of it all is too much. I am only worried about being able to visit my family in the U.S. occasionally but, have no desire what so ever to EVER live there again.
Shame on you United States for this monetary slavery. We are not rich and my husbands income supports me *I have lupus and RA* AND my son with disabilities. Now you want me to feel like I’m a servant to you though I’ve done nothing wrong. This puts such a hardship on people.
I have already applied for my Canadian citizenship, I want to renounce American citizenship and not be penalized for traveling on my CANADIAN passport. Thirty years of not living in the U.S. and we still have to contend with this ridiculousness.
Pingback: The New Berlin Wall IV: A reader’s comment « The Righteous Investor
Pingback: A Censored Forum is an Oxymoron: Why the Expat Forum is not a safe place for conversation and what we can learn from our experience there | The Isaac Brock Society
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society - FATCA Fact Finding Forum – The Human Consequences of FATCA – Peter W. Dunn
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society
Pingback: These are the Neanderthals that claim the right to tax you no matter where you live | The Righteous Investor
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society | Homelanders Abroad are drawing lines in the sand
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society | The disillusionment of an American expat: Reflexions on the fifth anniversary of my fifth year of relinquishment of United States Citizenship